Free Speech...or no speech at all
Last comment by theflyonthewall 1 month, 2 weeks ago.

Take Me To Post Comment Form

I’m sure everyone is aware that referencing God in a speech can be a dicey thing these days, especially if you are a graduating senior delivering a Valedictorian or Salutatorian speech.

Well, for Salutatorian Brooks Hamby, the Brawley Union High School District in Brawley, California made it very clear to him that God had no place in his speech.

Speaking as their legal representatives, the San Diego law firm of Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud and Romo informed him in a ten page letter “It is well established in the Ninth Circuit and California that a public school salutatorian has no constitutional right to lead a prayer or include sectarian or proselytizing content in his/her graduation speech.”

Really? Is that so? Let’s see who says what about this, starting with Brawley School Superintendent Dr. Hasmik Danielian, who states in her Superintendent’s Message that “The Brawley Union High School District is committed to equal opportunities for all individuals…shall be free from discrimination based on gender, sex, race, color, religion…” Hmmh.

What about the Ninth Circuit of the Court of Appeals. Research shows they had decided several issues concerning religious speech in the case of John Niemeyer et al versus the Oroville Union High School District et al in their ruling #99-16550.

First, they decided that “(a graduation) invocation would not have been private speech…and therefore constituted impermissible government sponsorship of religious activity under the Establishment Clause.”

Most important to Hamby’s case was that the Ninth Circuit’s Oroville ruling did not address the mention of God in a Valedictorian or Salutatorian’s speech. That issue was very clearly not part of this suit.

Therefore, the Ninth Court of Appeals had NOT ruled that Hamby’s speech would violate the Establishment Clause as indicated by the Brawley Union School District’s lawyers.
Their final justification was that the California’ Constitution banned such speeches.

Here what their constitution actually says: Article One of the California Constitution’s Declaration of Rights Section Two Subsection a) states that “Every person may freely speak, write and publish his or her sentiments on all subjects, being responsible for the abuse of this right. A law may not restrain or abridge liberty of speech or press.”

It turns out that Hamby had submitted several versions of his speech for District approval. In response, the Brawley School District had, according to an article in Fox News, “redacted references to Jesus and the Christian faith in three previous versions of Hamby’s speech.

One administrator went so far as to redact every religious reference with a black marker – as if it were some sort of top-secret government document.”

So, what did Hamby do? According to the same Fox News article, he wrote a fourth version of his speech, which included his wish that “May the God of the Bible bless each and every one of you every day in the rest of your lives.”

What happened next? The proverbial you-know-what hit the old fan. Liberty Institute lawyers agreed to represent him. They, in turn, demanded that the school district apologize for censoring the boy’s speech.

The school district responded by insisting the school district was required by law to censor his speech in order to “avoid an Establishment Clause violation.”

So, as I am not a lawyer I checked out what this “Establishment Clause” actually states. According to Cornell University’s Legal Information Institute, the First Amendment's Establishment Clause “prohibits the government from making any law respecting an establishment of religion.”

This simply means there can be no official state religion, as there is in Japan (Shintoism). It also forbids any governmental preference of one religion/non-religion over any other. Hamby was a student, and a private individual, and certainly not a representative of our government!

In addition, the First Amendment itself states very clearly that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people…”

That, to me, is exactly what the Brawley Union High School District tried to do. This was religious censorship at its worst, as Hamby was simply asking God to bless all his fellow graduates and not win any one over to Christianity.

It’s no surprise to me that this happened in California, for it is there the concept of protecting free speech has really come to mean that an individual has no right to say anything at all!


Latest Activity: Jul 13, 2014 at 9:36 PM


Bookmark and Share
Forward This Blog
Print Blog
More Blogs by Regional
Send Regional a Message
Report Inappropriate Content


Blog has been viewed (314) times.

Bryant commented on Monday, Jul 14, 2014 at 13:16 PM

The Ninth Circuit is the most reversed appellate court in the nation. Their rulings are always suspect.. Not having read Hamby's speech, I can't reasonably comment on the school board's actions But from general observation, most are extremely conservative in their efforts to avoid any appearance of promoting anything remotely resembling a religious slant. Forgetting that most attendees just want to see their kids walk up on stage and get a diploma. "Speeches?! We don't need no stinking speeches!"

theflyonthewall commented on Monday, Jul 14, 2014 at 15:32 PM

The Ninth Circuit is notorious for off - the- wall decisions. If I were King of the Forest, the jurisdiction of this clown college would cover a small parking lot in Oakland.


Log In to post comments.

Previous blog entries by Regional
 
Map Story Of Ukraine Conflict
August 29, 2014
why all the fighting in the ukraine....from what started as an internal disagreement turned into a total breakdown of rule and order.... this obvious loss of control over the far away eastern region, long ignored by kiev politicians and feeling very upset about conditions in their cities... these feelings gave ...
Read More »
 
Islam: why different sects?
August 24, 2014
There have been seventy-two different sects in the Islamic religion recorded by Islamic historians Munshi Mehmoob ‘Alim and Abu-Manus al-Baghdadi. Some of them became political sects as well, while some of them rejected fundamental parts of the Islamic faith. Curiously enough, “Caliph Ibrahim” of the new Islamic State is known ...
Read More »
 
Ferguson: The Facts
August 21, 2014
At first glance, and if you believed what the parents and friend of the young man who was shot and killed said of the incident and their son, this young black man had been gunned down execution style, shot in the back as he walked away from the police officer ...
Read More »
 
Robin Williams is Gone...A Tragic Loss
August 12, 2014
It is hard to imagine, but actor Robin Williams is dead, apparently by his own hand. According to reports, he had recently checked himself into a clinic to attempt to ensure his sobriety, for he had been very depressed as of late. His wife, graphic designer Susan Schneider, whom he ...
Read More »
 
Israel and Hamas: Who is in the right?
August 06, 2014
Hallelujah! Hamas has finally agreed along with Israel to a cease-fire for 72 hours, based on the exact same conditions to stop fighting as the cease-fire they refused to sign off on one month ago. Too bad that Hamas actually rules Gaza and the Gazans have no say in their ...
Read More »
 
[View More Blogs...]





 
Powered by
Morris Technology