Government by intimidation?
Last comment by Bryant 1 year, 4 months ago.

Take Me To Post Comment Form

Letter to the editor which may or not see the light of day in print.

I never fail to marvel at George Will's ability to wield language in such a fashion as to denigrate liberals (anyone to the left of Rick Santorum) and trash those he purports to support (law enforcement). His omission of facts also serves to said him in his effort. In the May 6th edition of the Herald, his column titled “Government by Intimidation” is only the latest effort. I will not attempt to refute his entire article (the Herals has its limit) but pick three quotes.

“While sheriff's deputies used floodlights...armed raiders seized documents...” Really? Why does Mr. Will feel the need to describe the selfsame deputies as “armed raiders”? Is there a difference in their classification when they're using a floodlight as opposed to seizing documents? A shallow ploy to make the execution of judicially issued search warrant seem nefarious.

In discussing the use of John Doe summonses he laments, “The identities of the targets are kept secret, and the targets are silenced...preventing public discussion...” Unfortunately for Mr. Will this is one of the purposes of a John Doe summons. The secrecy also serves those under investigation by “prevent(ing) testimony that may be mistaken or untrue or irrelevant from becoming public” according Hurley, Burish and Stanton, a Wisconsin law firm.

Finally he equates the investigation with “...govenment power wielded secretively for vengeance and intimidation.” and tells Wisconsin they need to “...eliminat(e) corrupt prosecutors and processes...” Let's just skip the inconvenient fact that there has been no proof of prosecutorial misconduct. Under Wisconsin statute 968.26 establishing John Doe investigations, affirmed by the Wisonsin Supreme Court in 1889, these investigations are overseen by a district court judge. In the specific instance here, there were five separate jurisdictions with three Democratic and two Republican prosecutors. Seems to me it would be difficult for all five of these elected individuals to wish vengeance upon the governor.

Finally just a couple of facts Mr. Will conventiently omitted. This investigation was apparently an outgrowth of a prior John Doe investigation of Scott Walker while he was Milwaukee County executive. An investigation which led to the conviction of three former aids, one political appointee, and a major campaign contributor. Also, the Republican Attorney General was requested to oversee the investigation and took four months to decide he didn't want to get involved. The investigation was then led by a former Federal Prosecutor, Francis Schmitz.

If you were to take Mr. Will's column at face value, you would be led to believe that a veritable mob of progressive, liberal prosecutors have trampled willy-nilly over the rights of poor citizens in Wisconsin and, “Oh, the humanity! Can nothing be done to relieve us of these jackbooted thugs?” Fortunately such is not the case. Unfortunately, when a columnist omits necessary information and uses inflammatory language to reach his conclusion (the one he's trying to sell you), he's planting seeds in salted earth.

Sources: The second site was informative and probably would mirror Georgia's provisions for John Doe summonses. I simpy lacked the fortitude to find out.

Latest Activity: May 18, 2014 at 8:16 PM

Bookmark and Share
Forward This Blog
Print Blog
More Blogs by Bryant
Send Bryant a Message
Report Inappropriate Content

Blog has been viewed (1718) times.

Charles_and_Angie_Howell commented on Monday, May 19, 2014 at 07:14 AM

Bryant, I won't disagree with your blog, though I have not read the aforementioned George Will piece. There are plenty of other conservative examples of, "...when a columnist omits necessary information and uses inflammatory language to reach his conclusion (the one he's trying to sell you), he's planting seeds in salted earth."

I will anxiously await your next blog on that liberal miscreant Gene Lyons, or maybe you'd like to take on one on of the big boys (girls) from CNN, CBS, NBC, ABC or the perhaps the Godfather of them all.... Al Sharpton.

Bryant commented on Monday, May 19, 2014 at 13:44 PM

Charlie, I refuse to watch MSNBC (used to watch Morning Joe until it degenerated into a "who can talk fastest and loudest") or CNN and I have no use for Al Sharpton in any capacity. Same goes for Fox News - it is simply the mirror image of MSNBC. Unfortunately these days, it takes a low of effort to be informed and not propagandized. Some days I'm simply not up to the effort.

Charles_and_Angie_Howell commented on Monday, May 19, 2014 at 14:40 PM


I watch the news (CBS), but I listen for the bias and only follow the facts.

If I had to make my living that way (TV media) - "...I'd shoot myself!"

Stolen from the scout (Jon Lovitz) in 'A League of Their Own.'

Bryant commented on Tuesday, May 20, 2014 at 09:16 AM

I watch Al-Jazeera America, PBS News Hour, and one hour of the CBS morning news. And ocassionally listen to NPR - but not often, I enjoy music too much and news not su much.

Log In to post comments.

Previous blog entries by Bryant
Speculation in the Media
September 17, 2015
Here's a link to a talk Michael Crichton gave in 2002 about speculation in (not only) the media. It is as relevant today if not more so. As a viewer of Sunday morning news shows such as Meet the Press, I find the quality and information presented of continually eroding ...
Read More »
American Oligarchy
September 10, 2015
A link to Der Spiegel article about American financing of elections which I found relevant in today's atmosphere.
Read More »
Where is everyone?
September 07, 2015
Well, there certainly has been a paucity of posts for the last month or so. Is it because everyone has run out of things to be a) outraged about, b) ecstatic about, c) wondrous of, or d) none of the above? Have those lower than a snake's belly in a ...
Read More »
Canfederate Memorial
July 12, 2015
In Dublin where I grew up, there was a memorial to Confederate soldiers in front of the “old” library downtown. It's provenance and inscription were probably similar, I presume, to the one at the Bulloch courthouse.. As a youth, I read it, filed it away as history, and forgot it. ...
Read More »
Charleston Shooting
June 23, 2015
A horrific act by a sick (not insane) person and major news coverage is about removing the confederate flag from the grounds of the state capitol and from Wal -Mart. Rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic rather than answering the question, "Where's all this damn water coming from? "
Read More »
[View More Blogs...]

Powered by
Morris Technology