I have been a customer from time to time ,and I think that your store offers an array of unique merchandise and a hometown feel not available in other stores. I hope that you can find an alternate location because I think it would be a shame to lose another Statesboro institution. Good luck!
My family and I have browsed your merchandise at times and always found the staff to be friendly and efficient. The stuff we bought was good quality.
I suggest you roll with the flow. If the S'Mall doesn't feel that your store contributes to the overall appeal, bump 'em. Find a new place.
I know Brooklet has plenty of open storefronts. Seems like there are open storefronts in the 'Boro as well. Check up near the Pro Audio, as well as out near Ogeechee Tech. Main Street is also an option.
Best of Luck!